Best Electric Smokers for Beginners: 5 Picks Compared

The best electric smoker for beginners, for most first-time cooks, is the Royal Gourmet SE2805. It keeps the job simple: one adjustable controller, a built-in thermometer to check the cabinet, a 1,350 W element in an insulated chamber, and 454 square inches on three racks, per Royal Gourmet. At 42.1 lb, per the listing, it is also the lightest of the five smokers below, which counts if it has to come out of a shed for every cook. Its one real gap is that neither Royal Gourmet nor the listing prints a temperature scale for the controller, so you will learn your settings from the thermometer over the first few cooks. If you would rather start from an exact number, the Masterbuilt 30-Inch Analog marks its dial up to 275°F, and the Masterbuilt 710 WiFi lets you set time and temperature on a panel or in an app.

All five picks were chosen for someone who has never run a smoker. Each one plugs into a household outlet, smolders wood chips for flavor, and holds its heat with a thermostat rather than a fire you have to feed. Where they differ is in how much they tell you while they work: a plain control and a thermometer, a marked dial, a digital panel with a timer, a built-in meat probe, or alerts on your phone. Every spec below comes from the Amazon listing for that exact product or, where we name the maker, from the maker’s own US product page or FAQ.

This guide is general product information, not repair or electrical safety advice. Follow the safety instructions in your product’s manual, supervise children, and contact the manufacturer or an authorized service center if a product sparks, overheats, or has a damaged cord.

We earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. Commissions never affect our rankings or PelletSmokeLab Scores.

Our Picks for a First Electric Smoker

• Best Overall: Royal Gourmet SE2805 Analog Electric Smoker. An adjustable analog controller with a built-in thermometer, a 1,350 W element, and three racks, per Royal Gourmet, in the lightest cabinet of the five at 42.1 lb, per the listing.
• Best Analog Dial: Masterbuilt 30-Inch Analog Electric Smoker (MB20070210). The only analog pick whose maker publishes a temperature range for the dial, 100 to 275°F, and the highest element wattage stated for any pick, a 1,500 W replacement part, per Masterbuilt.
• Best App-Controlled Pick: Masterbuilt 710 WiFi Digital Electric Smoker. The only pick with WiFi: set cook time and temperature from 100 to 275°F on the panel or in the Masterbuilt app, with one meat probe included, per Masterbuilt.

The two EAST OAK cabinets carry no title. The Ridgewood adds a viewing window and a built-in meat probe, according to the listing, and East Oak publishes a spec table for it; the Classic has the same rack area and side chip loader without the window or probe. On paper both suit a beginner, but their Amazon listings share one pool of owner ratings, so we cannot credit those ratings to either model. Both are covered below.

Beginner Electric Smokers Compared

How We Chose

We searched Amazon US for electric smokers for beginners, an easy electric smoker, digital electric smokers for beginners, small electric smokers, electric smokers with a window, and Masterbuilt’s electric line. We removed cookbooks, accessories, replacement parts, and used or renewed listings. Each remaining smoker had to be sold new on Amazon US, clear our minimum average owner rating from a minimum number of owner ratings. We also cap how many picks this list shares with our general electric smoker coverage, so some familiar cabinets are left out on purpose.

All five are corded electric cabinets, and none of the listings mentions a 220 to 240 V supply or an overseas plug. We searched federal recall records by brand and by model number for all five and found no matching recall notice. We then checked that each maker still sells its model. Royal Gourmet lists the SE2805 on its own store. Masterbuilt lists the 30-Inch Analog and the 710 WiFi, and its FAQ answers questions on seasoning, wood chips, and extension cords for its electric smokers. East Oak sells both the Ridgewood in silver and the Classic, with a written spec table on the Ridgewood page only.

Best Overall has to still be sold by its maker, fit the beginner brief, and clear a higher average owner rating than the rest of the list requires. Four picks could not take it. The two EAST OAK listings show exactly the same owner ratings even though East Oak sells the Classic and the Ridgewood as separate models, so neither has ratings of its own; we lowered both of their PelletSmokeLab Scores by 0.3 for that reason. The Masterbuilt 30-Inch Analog already holds the top spot in another of our guides, and we give one model that spot only once. The Masterbuilt 710 WiFi sits below the higher rating bar. That left our rule for smaller categories: compact electric cabinets like the SE2805 draw far fewer Amazon owner ratings than long-running models, so we allow a Best Overall with a smaller base of ratings as long as it clears the same higher average.

The SE2805 clears it, it is on Royal Gourmet’s own store, and Amazon sells it new. Royal Gourmet’s product page pitches it at cooks “from weekend beginner to backyard pitmaster,” and, like the Masterbuilt analog, it runs on a single control. We weighed one gap: Royal Gourmet publishes neither a temperature scale for the controller nor a manual online, so the printed manual in the box is your reference. After the Best Overall, the list follows the titled picks, then the Ridgewood ahead of the Classic because it adds a probe and a window. The PelletSmokeLab Score on each card is calculated separately with the method on our How We Review page and does not set this order.

How to Choose the Best Electric Smoker for Beginners

A beginner electric smoker should make the first few cooks predictable. These six questions sort the five picks for a first-time cook.

Dial or panel: how much do you want to set?

The SE2805 and the Masterbuilt analog are the simplest to operate: you turn a control, and the element cycles on and off to hold the heat. What separates them is what the control tells you. Masterbuilt marks its dial up to 275°F and gives a 100 to 275°F range in its spec table, so you start from a known setting. Royal Gourmet pairs its adjustable controller with a built-in thermometer but publishes no scale, so on the first cook you set the control, wait for the cabinet to settle, read the thermometer, and adjust. Write down where the control sat when the cabinet held the temperature you wanted; that note becomes your starting point next time.

The three digital cabinets let you enter a number instead. Both EAST OAK models have a panel with a 12-hour timer, according to their listings, and the Masterbuilt 710 sets cook time and temperature from 100 to 275°F on its panel or in the Masterbuilt app, per Masterbuilt. A timer helps when a cook will end while you are away from the yard. Neither analog model lists a timer, so plan to be home at the end of the cook.

Will you watch the meat or the cabinet?

A cabinet thermometer or display reads the air around the food. Whether the food is done depends on its internal temperature, which the cabinet reading cannot tell you. Two picks build a probe in. The Ridgewood has a built-in meat probe and a viewing window, according to the listing, so you can follow the cook without opening the door. The Masterbuilt 710 ships with one probe, accepts up to four, and shows their readings in the Masterbuilt app, per Masterbuilt.

With the SE2805, the Masterbuilt analog, or the EAST OAK Classic, budget for a separate meat thermometer from the start. Whichever route you take, check the USDA FSIS safe minimum internal temperature chart for the food you are cooking, and treat a recipe’s target for tender, sliceable, or pull-apart meat as a separate number from that safety minimum.

How will you add wood chips?

Every pick here makes smoke by heating wood chips over the element, and on a long cook you will add more. The Masterbuilt 710 and both EAST OAK cabinets have a side loader, so the chips go in from outside while the main door stays shut. The Masterbuilt analog uses a removable chip tray and the SE2805 a chip box; neither maker lists a side loader for those two, so read the manual for how to top up chips during a cook.

Less is more at the start. In its smoker FAQ, Masterbuilt says never to add more than ½ cup of wood chips at a time, and to wait until the earlier chips have stopped smoking before adding more. The same FAQ says its electric smokers are designed for wood chips only, and that dry chips burn faster with more intense smoke while chips soaked in water for about 30 minutes burn slower with milder smoke. That gives a new owner an easy first comparison: run one cook with dry chips and the next with soaked ones, then keep whichever smoke level your household prefers.

What if the smoker makes little smoke?

Seeing thin smoke on a low setting is a fair worry on a first cook, and the EAST OAK Ridgewood listing addresses it directly. According to the listing, the smoker may not produce constant smoke below 250°F, so East Oak’s recommendation is to set it to 250 to 275°F first, let it build smoke, then put the food in and adjust the temperature. That guidance is written for the Ridgewood; for the other models, check the manual. Masterbuilt’s FAQ covers the other half of the routine: feed chips in small batches, and only after the previous batch has stopped smoking.

Are you ready for the first run?

A new cabinet carries oil and residue from the factory, and the makers want it burned off before any food goes in. Masterbuilt’s FAQ says to leave the water pan in place but empty, run the smoker at 275°F for three hours, add ½ cup of wood chips during the last 45 minutes, then power it off and let it cool completely.

The EAST OAK Ridgewood listing gives a different routine. It says to clean the interior with a wet sponge and mild detergent and let it air-dry, wipe the inside walls with a little cooking oil while keeping oil off the smoke box, heating elements, grease tray, and water tray, keep the water and smoke boxes empty with the vent open, then run the smoker at 275°F for 2 hours and let it cool. The listing adds that some oil smoke and odor during that first heat-up is normal. Royal Gourmet does not publish first-run steps online, so use the manual that ships with the SE2805. Because the routines differ, follow the one written for your model, and schedule it a day before your first real cook so the smoker is cool and ready.

Where will it plug in and stand?

Measure from your outdoor outlet to the spot where the smoker can sit before you order, because that distance decides if you need an extension cord at all. If you do, Masterbuilt’s FAQ sets the rules for its smokers: an outdoor cord marked with the suffix letters “W-A” and tagged “Suitable for Use with Outdoor Appliances,” grounding terminals in working condition, a diameter heavier than 16 AWG, and a length of no more than 25 feet. Masterbuilt also notes that a smaller AWG number means a larger wire diameter.

Placement rules matter just as much for a beginner who wants to tuck the smoker out of the weather. Masterbuilt says not to use its smokers in covered areas, including garages or covered porches, or on combustible surfaces, and not within 10 feet of any structure or building. We did not find manuals for the Royal Gourmet or East Oak models on their makers’ sites, so read the cord and clearance instructions in the box before the first cook, and follow your own manual where it differs from Masterbuilt’s.

How much smoker do you need, and where will it live?

Capacity is easy to overbuy on a first smoker. Masterbuilt says its analog model fits up to 3 chickens, 2 turkeys, 3 pork butts, or 3 racks of ribs on 535 square inches, and that the 710 fits up to 8 pork butts on 710 square inches. The SE2805 has 454 square inches on three racks, per Royal Gourmet, and both EAST OAK cabinets list 725 square inches on four racks. For a couple smoking a rack of ribs or a pork shoulder on weekends, three racks are plenty; for a family of five that hosts gatherings, a four-rack cabinet leaves room to grow.

Weight matters if the smoker goes back into storage after every cook. The SE2805 is the lightest at 42.1 lb, per the listing, followed by the Masterbuilt analog at 49.9 lb and the 710 at 50.7 lb, per their listings. East Oak lists the Ridgewood at 59 lb, while its Amazon listing says 52.3 lb, the same figure the Classic listing gives. The Ridgewood rolls on two rear wheels, per East Oak, and the Classic listing describes rear wheels and a handle. Heights run from 32.2 inches on the EAST OAK cabinets, per their listings, to 40.6 inches on the 710, per Masterbuilt.

Warranty and parts

Royal Gourmet’s FAQ gives a 1-year full warranty from the date of original retail purchase against defects in materials and workmanship, and says the paint finish and rust are not covered. Masterbuilt lists a 1-year warranty for both of its models and sells parts by model number, including a controller kit and a temperature probe for the 710. East Oak’s spec table lists a 3-year warranty for the Ridgewood. Keep the receipt and register the smoker if the maker asks you to.

Who Should Look Elsewhere

• You have no outdoor outlet within reach. All five plug in, and Masterbuilt caps any extension cord for its smokers at 25 feet.
• You want to grill or sear. Every pick with a published range tops out at 275°F, which is smoking and slow-cooking heat.
• You want exact numbers on an analog control. Skip the SE2805; the Masterbuilt analog is the analog pick with a marked range.
• You want owner ratings tied to one model. Skip both EAST OAK cabinets, whose listings share one pool of ratings.
• You would rather not use an app. The 710’s WiFi is its main draw; the EAST OAK panels give you a timer without one.
• You need to lift the smoker often. Skip the Ridgewood, which East Oak lists at 59 lb.

Electric Smokers for Beginners: FAQ

What is the best electric smoker for a beginner?

Our Best Overall is the Royal Gourmet SE2805: an adjustable controller with a built-in thermometer, a 1,350 W element, three racks, and the lowest weight of our five picks. If you want a marked dial, the Masterbuilt 30-Inch Analog reads up to 275°F; if you want a timer, alerts, and an included probe, the Masterbuilt 710 WiFi adds them through an app.

Should a beginner buy an analog or a digital electric smoker?

Buy analog if you will be home for the whole cook and like having one control to learn. Buy digital if you want to enter an exact temperature and a cook time, or if the cook will finish while you are out. Among our picks, the digital models are the only ones with a listed timer or an included meat probe.

Why is my new electric smoker making so little smoke?

Check the temperature first. The EAST OAK Ridgewood listing says that model may not produce constant smoke below 250°F and suggests starting at 250 to 275°F to build smoke before adding food. Then check the chips: Masterbuilt says to add no more than ½ cup at a time, and only once the previous batch has stopped smoking.

How do I break in a new electric smoker?

Run it empty first, following your own manual. Masterbuilt’s routine is three hours at 275°F with an empty water pan and ½ cup of chips in the last 45 minutes. The EAST OAK Ridgewood listing calls for cleaning and lightly oiling the interior walls, then 2 hours at 275°F with the water and smoke boxes empty.

Do I need a separate meat thermometer with an electric smoker?

With three of our five picks, yes: the SE2805, the Masterbuilt analog, and the EAST OAK Classic do not list a meat probe. The Ridgewood has one built in, according to its listing, and the Masterbuilt 710 includes one, per Masterbuilt. Either way, compare the reading with the USDA FSIS safe minimum internal temperature chart for that food.

Final Thoughts

Pick the smoker that removes the part of the first cook you are least sure about: the setting, the timing, or the meat. Our picks by need:

• Best Overall: Royal Gourmet SE2805 Analog Electric Smoker. For one control and a built-in thermometer in the lightest cabinet.
• Best Analog Dial: Masterbuilt 30-Inch Analog Electric Smoker (MB20070210). For a single dial with a published range.
• Best App-Controlled Pick: Masterbuilt 710 WiFi Digital Electric Smoker. For setting and checking the cook from your phone, with a probe in the box.

Whichever you choose, do the empty first run, start with a small handful of chips, and let a thermometer in the meat decide when dinner is ready.

About the author