Best Pellet Smokers for Low-and-Slow BBQ: 8 Picks Compared

The best pellet smoker for most backyards holds a steady low temperature for hours, puts real smoke on the meat at that low end, and carries enough pellets to get through a long cook without a refill run in the middle of the night. Our Best Overall pick, the Traeger Pro 22, does that with a low Smoke setting, an 18 lb hopper, and 572 sq in of grate space on two levels, per Traeger. We compared eight pellet smokers from Traeger, Pit Boss, and Z Grills, and this guide judges them as smokers first: how low each one goes, what each maker offers for extra smoke, how much fuel the hopper holds, and how each one copes with wind and cold.

Every spec below comes from the Amazon listing for that exact product or, where we name the maker, from the maker’s own product page or owner’s manual. Where the two disagree, we say which number we used and why.

This guide is general product information, not repair or electrical safety advice. Follow the safety instructions in your product’s manual, supervise children, and contact the manufacturer or an authorized service center if a product sparks, overheats, or has a damaged cord.

Propane and charcoal grills are for outdoor use only (NFPA), and no grill should be used inside a home, garage or camper because of the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning (CDC); for pellet and wood-fired models, follow your manual.

We earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. Commissions never affect our rankings or PelletSmokeLab Scores.

Our Top Pellet Smoker Picks

• Best Overall: Traeger Pro 22. The simplest setup here for long smokes: a low Smoke setting, an 18 lb hopper, and 572 sq in on two grates, per Traeger.
• Best for Cold-Weather Smoking: Traeger Ironwood 885. The only pick here whose maker describes an insulated dual-wall body, plus a Super Smoke mode usable from 165°F to 225°F, per Traeger.
• Best for All-Day Cooks: Pit Boss 850 Navigator. A 30 lb hopper, the biggest among the models with a published hopper size, plus 932 sq in of cooking space, the most of the eight, and a P Setting for tuning the low end, per Pit Boss.
• Best for Easy Cleanup: Traeger Woodridge. The only pick whose maker describes one container that catches both grease and pellet ash, plus a 24 lb hopper and app control, per Traeger.
• Best Tabletop Pick: Z Grills ZPG-200APro. The only tabletop model here: 25 x 20 x 13 in, 40 lb, and 202 sq in of cooking space, according to the Amazon listing.

Three smokers carry no title. The Pit Boss 440 Mahogany sits second in our research order, but its 5 lb hopper is the smallest among the models with a published hopper size, which is a real limit for a smoker. The Z Grills 600D2 sits fifth; its listing names a PID controller but gives no hopper capacity. The Pit Boss 700 Carbon sits eighth because its Amazon listing shows the same rating data as a different, smaller model, so we cannot tell how much of that feedback is about the 700.

Pellet Smokers Compared

How We Chose

We started with Amazon US search results for pellet smokers, wood pellet grill smokers, and pellet smokers from Traeger, Pit Boss, Z Grills, and Camp Chef, then removed accessories, used or renewed listings, and anything that is not a pellet-fired cooker. Each remaining smoker had to be sold new on Amazon US, average at least 4.0 out of 5 from at least 30 owner ratings, and come from a grill maker that publishes its own product specifications. We kept no more than three models per brand. Where two listings turned out to be the same grill, or two different grills showed identical rating data, we kept only one of them.

All eight are plug-in grills sold for the US market. We read each listing for 220 to 240 volt ratings or non-US plugs and found none. Traeger lists 120V AC for the Pro 22 and the Ironwood 885, Pit Boss’s owner’s manuals for the Navigator 850 and the Carbon 700 list AC 110 to 120V, and the Z Grills ZPG-200A manual says to plug into a 110 Volt AC grounded outlet. We could not find a published voltage for the Woodridge, the 440 Mahogany, or the 600D2.

We also searched the recall records of the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission for each brand and model. None of the eight matched a recall. The only Traeger pellet grill recall we found there covers the Scout and Ranger portable grills, where CPSC says grease could leak from the drip tray; it does not name the Pro 22, the Ironwood 885, or the Woodridge. Traeger’s other recall on file is for its Flatrock propane flat top, which is not a pellet grill. We found no CPSC recall under the Pit Boss or Z Grills names.

Next we checked the makers’ own pages. Traeger’s product pages for the Pro 22, the Ironwood 885, and the Woodridge confirm hopper sizes, cooking areas, and smoke features, and the Ironwood 885 owner’s manual and Woodridge owner’s manual explain Super Smoke and Keep Warm. Pit Boss’s pages for the Navigator 850 and the Carbon 700, their owner’s manuals (Navigator 850, Carbon 700), and the Pit Boss FAQ cover the P Setting, the Smoke setting, and normal temperature swings. Z Grills publishes a ZPG-200A owner’s manual. We could not find maker product pages for the 440 Mahogany, the 600D2, or the ZPG-200APro, so their specs come from the Amazon listings alone.

Best Overall has to be a pellet smoker from one of those brands that averages at least 4.2 out of 5, with 1,000 or more owner ratings for the top tier, and its maker still has to list it. Two picks cleared that bar: the Traeger Pro 22 and the Pit Boss 440 Mahogany. The Pro 22 comes first under our Best Overall rules, Traeger still lists it, and its 18 lb hopper beats the 440’s 5 lb by a wide margin, which matters more for low-and-slow cooking than any other difference between the two. The rest follow our research order. The PelletSmokeLab Score on each card is calculated separately with the method on our How We Review page and does not set this order. We lowered two scores under our published listing rules: the Navigator 850 by 0.2, because its listing says two meat probes come in the box while Pit Boss lists one probe and two probe ports, and the 700 Carbon by 0.3, because its listing shows the same rating data as the listing for the smaller Carbon 500.

How Each Pick Handles Low-and-Slow Smoking

Traeger Pro 22: the straightforward smoker

Traeger describes the Pro 22 as running from “a low and slow Smoke setting to a high of 450°F,” with an 18 lb hopper, two porcelain-coated grates totaling 572 sq in, one meat probe, and a 6 ft power cord. The Amazon listing puts the bottom of that range at 180°F and says the Digital Pro Controller holds within plus or minus 15 degrees. For a brisket or pork shoulder you would spend most of the cook at the bottom of the dial, where the FAQ on Traeger’s product page says food picks up more smoke flavor. The trade-offs: no WiFi (Traeger says so plainly), Traeger’s page does not list a Super Smoke mode, and nothing in Traeger’s description mentions insulation. Traeger files the Pro 22 under “Legacy Grills” in its site menu and describes it as “the original Pro Series (Gen 1),” so availability may change. Look elsewhere if you want to watch the cook from your phone or if you smoke through hard winters.

Pit Boss 440 Mahogany: small hopper, sear option

According to the Amazon listing, the 440 Mahogany (model PB440D2) runs from 180°F to 500°F on a dial-in digital control board, offers 518 sq in of cooking space, and has a Flame Broiler Lever that switches between direct and indirect heat. Its hopper holds 5 lb, the smallest among the models with a published hopper size, so on an all-day cook expect to top it up far more often than the Traeger picks or the other two Pit Boss models. Pit Boss’s FAQ, written for its pellet grills in general, puts the normal Smoke setting range at 180°F to 210°F. A search for the PB440D2 on Pit Boss’s US site returned a replacement probe but no grill page when we checked, so we could not confirm its current status with Pit Boss. Look elsewhere if you plan overnight cooks or want app control.

Traeger Ironwood 885: built for cold and extra smoke

The Ironwood 885 is the most smoke-focused grill in this group on paper. Traeger lists a 165°F to 500°F range, a Super Smoke mode, insulated dual-wall construction, a D2 controller that adjusts in 5°F steps, WiFIRE app control, a hopper pellet sensor, and a bottom grate that moves between a smoke position and a sear position. The owner’s manual says Super Smoke works only when the grill is between 165°F and 225°F, which is exactly the low-and-slow window. Traeger says the insulated build reduces temperature fluctuation and keeps cooking consistent “even in cold conditions.” The costs are size and bulk: 885 sq in, a 20 lb hopper, and 175 lb per Traeger (the listing says 170.2 lb; we use Traeger’s figure). Like the Pro 22, it sits under Traeger’s “Legacy Grills” menu. Look elsewhere if you have a small patio or no reliable 2.4 GHz WiFi near the grill and want the app features.

Traeger Woodridge: newer platform, easier cleanup

Traeger introduces the Woodridge on its product page as “the all-new Traeger Woodridge grill.” Traeger lists 860 sq in across two racks (520 and 340 sq in), a 24 lb hopper, a 500°F maximum, WiFIRE, a wired meat probe, Bluetooth meat thermometer compatibility, and the EZ-Clean Grease & Ash Keg, which gathers drippings and pellet ash in one container. The Amazon listing gives the range as 180°F to 500°F. For smokers, note what is missing: Traeger lists Super Smoke on the Woodridge Pro, not on this base Woodridge. The manual describes a Keep Warm mode, set from the app, that holds the grill at 180°F; Traeger notes that Keep Warm is not designed to cook food to food-safety standards, so treat it as a holding setting. The listing and Traeger both state a 10-year limited warranty. Look elsewhere if you want a dedicated extra-smoke button at this size.

Z Grills 600D2: PID control, thin documentation

According to the Amazon listing, the 600D2 uses an upgraded PID controller that can be set from 180°F to 450°F, auto-start ignition, and 572 sq in of cooking space, the same area as the Pro 22. It adds a side shelf with tool hooks, a bottom storage cabinet, and two wheels with brakes, and the listing names a 3-year quality assurance. The listing does not give a hopper capacity or any extra-smoke mode, and we found no 600D2 page or manual on the Z Grills site, so we cannot fill those gaps from the maker. That makes it harder to plan a long cook than with the models that have a published hopper size. Look elsewhere if you want app control or a published hopper size before you buy.

Z Grills ZPG-200APro: smoking at small scale

The ZPG-200APro is a tabletop pellet grill. According to the Amazon listing, it measures 25 x 20 x 13 in, weighs 40 lb, offers 202 sq in of cooking area, and runs from 180°F to 375°F “and higher” on a digital control system. The Z Grills owner’s manual for the ZPG-200A tells you to start on the SMOKE setting with the lid open and to plug into a 110 Volt AC grounded outlet. At 202 sq in it has a bit more than a third of the Pro 22’s grate area, so it suits small cooks, not a party spread. The listing gives no hopper capacity. Look elsewhere if you cook for a crowd or want to run long overnight smokes without refilling.

Pit Boss 850 Navigator: the most fuel and space

Pit Boss lists the Navigator 850 with 932 sq in of cooking space, the most of the eight, and a 30 lb hopper, the largest among the models with a published hopper size, plus WiFi and Bluetooth, a 180°F to 500°F digital control in 5°F steps, fan-forced convection, and a Flame Broiler Lever for direct-flame searing. For smoking, the useful part is the P Setting. The owner’s manual explains that at the lowest temperature setting the P value controls how long the auger pauses between pellet feeds, so you can push more smoke flavor at a low cooking temperature; the default P-4 feeds pellets for 18 seconds and pauses for 115. It is also big: 58.7 in wide and 174.2 lb, per the manual. One listing note: the Amazon listing says two meat probes are included, while Pit Boss lists one probe and two probe ports. Look elsewhere if your patio is tight.

Pit Boss 700 Carbon: simple dial, mid-size hopper

Pit Boss lists the Carbon 700 with 718 sq in of cooking space, a 13.5 lb hopper with a cleanout, a 180°F to 500°F digital LCD controller, one meat probe, and a 3-year warranty. Its owner’s manual shows a dial with a SMOKE preset, which Pit Boss says runs the grill at its lowest temperature without the fire going out, followed by fixed steps from 200°F up to 475°F and HIGH. The manual lists 98.10 lb, which matches the listing. There is no P Setting, no app, and no insulation in Pit Boss’s description, so it is a basic smoker with more grate space than the Pro 22 and a smaller hopper. Its Amazon listing shares rating data with the Carbon 500, which is why it sits last. Look elsewhere if you want fine control at the low end.

How to Choose a Pellet Smoker for Low-and-Slow BBQ

Most pellet grills are sold as six-in-one or eight-in-one cookers, and the top temperature gets the headlines. For smoking, the bottom of the range and what happens there matter more.

Start with the low end of the range

Both Traeger and Pit Boss tie more smoke flavor to lower cooking temperatures (details in the FAQ below). Seven of these eight list 180°F as their lowest setting; the Ironwood 885 goes to 165°F. A lower floor gives you more room in that smoky window, but what the grill does at that floor matters just as much.

Know what the smoke feature actually does

The names sound alike but work differently. Traeger’s Super Smoke on the Ironwood 885 only runs between 165°F and 225°F, per the manual. Pit Boss’s P Setting on the Navigator 850 changes the pause between pellet feeds at the lowest setting, and Pit Boss’s FAQ says it has no effect on temperature at any other set point. The Carbon 700 has a SMOKE preset that Pit Boss says runs the grill at its lowest temperature, and the ZPG-200A manual has you start on a SMOKE dial position.

Size the hopper to your longest cook

Hopper sizes here run from 5 lb on the Pit Boss 440 to 30 lb on the Navigator 850, with the Carbon 700 at 13.5 lb, the Pro 22 at 18 lb, the Ironwood 885 at 20 lb, and the Woodridge at 24 lb. None of these makers publishes a burn rate for these models on the pages we read, so plan around capacity: if your usual cook is an overnight brisket, a bigger hopper means fewer trips outside to check fuel. The Ironwood’s pellet sensor, which reports the pellet level in the Traeger app, helps with that, as does the viewing window the Amazon listing describes on the Navigator’s hopper.

Plan for wind and cold

Weather changes how a pellet grill holds heat. Traeger credits the Ironwood 885’s dual-wall insulation for consistent cooking even in cold conditions, and Pit Boss’s Navigator 850 manual says cool outdoor air can weaken the heat inside the grill, which is why it suggests a lower P Setting in cooler weather. Traeger’s Woodridge manual also warns that the controller’s display may be damaged when the outside temperature drops below -20°F or rises above 120°F. If you smoke through winter, the Ironwood is the only pick here whose maker describes an insulated body.

Match grate space to what you smoke

Maker and listing capacity claims are a practical way to compare. The Pro 22 listing says it fits 5 racks of ribs or 4 whole chickens; the 600D2 listing gives the same 5 rib racks or 4 chickens for the same 572 sq in. Traeger rates the Woodridge at 8 rib racks, 6 chickens, or 6 pork butts, and the Ironwood 885 at 7 rib racks, 10 chickens, or 9 pork butts. These are the makers’ and listings’ figures, not ours, but they show the jump between the 500 and 900 sq in classes. A household of four that smokes a pork butt on weekends does not need 932 sq in.

Decide whether you want the app

App control lets you check and adjust a long cook from inside the house, which is the main reason to pay for it on a smoker. The Ironwood 885, the Woodridge, and the Navigator 850 offer it. Traeger’s Woodridge manual notes the grill connects only to a 2.4 GHz WiFi network and is not compatible with 5 GHz, so check your router signal at the spot where the grill will sit. The FAQ on Traeger’s Woodridge page also says you can use the grill without an internet connection.

Check your outlet and your space

Every pellet smoker needs power for the auger, fan, igniter, and controller. Traeger’s Woodridge manual says to plug into a grounded outlet with GFCI protection and, if you need an extension cord, to use one made for outdoor use (marked “W-A” or “W” on the jacket). Measure your patio too: the Navigator 850 is 58.7 in wide per Pit Boss’s manual, while the ZPG-200APro is 25 in wide per its listing.

Who Should Look Elsewhere

• You want a heavy, visible plume of smoke. Pit Boss’s FAQ says wood pellet grills burn extremely clean and produce a thin, bluish smoke that is almost invisible, and Pit Boss points owners who want more smoke to add-on smoke tubes. If a strong smoke flavor is the whole point for you, a pellet smoker may feel mild even with Super Smoke or a P Setting.
• You mostly sear steaks. These are smokers first. The Pro 22 tops out at 450°F per Traeger, and the 600D2 at 450°F per its listing. If high-heat searing is your main use, look at the two Pit Boss models with a Flame Broiler Lever or at a gas grill.
• You have no outdoor outlet. If running a cord to the grill is not practical, consider a charcoal smoker instead.
• You want to smoke overnight without checking fuel. Skip the 440 Mahogany and its 5 lb hopper, and the two Z Grills models whose listings give no hopper size.
• You need a grill you can move easily. The Ironwood 885 and Navigator 850 both weigh about 175 lb by their makers’ figures; only the ZPG-200APro is a tabletop design.

FAQ

What is the best pellet smoker?

For most people, the Traeger Pro 22: a low Smoke setting, an 18 lb hopper, and 572 sq in of grate space, per Traeger, without app features you may not need. If you smoke in cold weather or want a dedicated extra-smoke mode, the Ironwood 885 is the stronger smoker on paper. If you want the most fuel and space, the Pit Boss 850 Navigator has the most grate area of the eight and the largest hopper among the models with a published hopper size. And if you are after the best pellet smoker grill for searing as well as smoking, the two Pit Boss models with a Flame Broiler Lever fit that brief better than the Traegers.

What grill temperature gives the most smoke flavor?

The low end. Traeger says food cooked between 165°F and 225°F picks up more smoke flavor than food cooked hotter, and its Super Smoke mode only runs in that window. Pit Boss’s FAQ says cooking at lower temperatures produces more smoke and, for more smoke flavor, points owners to the lowest temperature setting or the Smoke setting. In its answers on startup and on a grill running hot in Smoke, the same FAQ gives 180°F to 210°F as the normal Smoke setting range. These are grill temperatures, not the internal temperature your food needs to reach; for that, check the USDA FSIS safe minimum internal temperature chart.

Why don’t I see much smoke coming out of my pellet smoker?

Pit Boss’s FAQ says this is normal: wood pellet grills burn extremely clean, and the smoke they make is a thin, bluish smoke that is almost invisible. The heavier white smoke at startup comes from pellets smoldering just before they ignite. Pit Boss adds that lowering the chimney cap to trap smoke causes temperature problems instead of adding smoke flavor.

Is it normal for a pellet smoker’s temperature to swing?

Yes, within limits. Pit Boss’s FAQ says its grills control heat by switching the auger on and off, which causes swings of plus or minus 25 degrees, and calls that completely normal. The Pro 22 listing claims the Digital Pro Controller holds within plus or minus 15 degrees. Traeger credits the Ironwood 885’s insulated build with reduced temperature fluctuation, and Pit Boss says a lower P Setting can minimize swings in the Smoke setting.

Can I use a pellet smoker in winter?

Yes, but expect it to work harder; the wind-and-cold section above covers what Traeger and Pit Boss say about cold weather. Keep pellets dry, too: Pit Boss’s FAQ warns that wet pellets swell, break apart, and can jam the auger.

Do pellet smokers need electricity?

Yes. Every pick here plugs in to run its auger, fan, igniter, and controller, and the makers that publish a voltage list 110 to 120V household power (see How We Chose for each model).

Final Thoughts

For low-and-slow BBQ, judge a pellet smoker by its low end, its hopper, and how it handles your weather before you look at the top temperature. Our picks by need:

• Best Overall: Traeger Pro 22. For weekend brisket and ribs on a mid-size grill with a simple controller.
• Best for Cold-Weather Smoking: Traeger Ironwood 885. For year-round smoking and a Super Smoke mode in the 165°F to 225°F window.
• Best for All-Day Cooks: Pit Boss 850 Navigator. For big cooks that need a 30 lb hopper and 932 sq in.
• Best for Easy Cleanup: Traeger Woodridge. For a newer Traeger with app control and one keg for grease and ash.
• Best Tabletop Pick: Z Grills ZPG-200APro. For small households and small cooks on a table or tailgate.

Whichever you choose, read the owner’s manual before the first cook and run the burn-in the maker describes before you put a brisket on.

Related Picks

• How to Smoke a Brisket on a Pellet Grill
• How to Smoke a Turkey on a Pellet Grill
• How to Smoke Ribs With the 3-2-1 Method

About the author